March Mayhem Round 1: As Tall As Lions vs. John Mayer

[Anton Djamoos]

Who is your favorite band out of these two? Be sure to read the replies for other users' cases for each band.

[owiseone35]

I'm sorry ATAL but I had to go with Mayer. He is just too good, but he also more discography too.

[JimGray]

Never been big on ATAL but John Mayer has some cool jams haha.

[hailthewarrior]

John Mayer

[bouttogetfancy]

as tall as lions

[NateFoundGlory]

Mayer. brilliant guitar player.

[The Summer Ends]

John Mayer is my hero.

[HangsLikeHeaven]

Atal

[blimpcityhero11]

Mayer.... He's also got a very entertaining blog. haha

[hf57]

john's just too good

[ThisIsNotDan]

John is one talented man, nothing against ATAL though

[Cue the Sun]

atal, definitely

[boomerangslang]

As Tall as Lions.

[Chris Fallon]

Tough one, but I like Mayer a bit more.

[OveriseFan]

This "March Mayhem" should have had some kind of seeding - then we could see both these great artists in the Final Four.

[Analog Rebellion]

John Mayer's live CD blew my fucking mind. So good.

[Gumbyjag]

John Mayer. ftw.

[atticusfinch]

atal probably wont win this, but they should.

[theguilt engine]

jm

[Shrillex]

As Tall As Loins.

[Broclee]

Wow, the results aren't what I was expecting. I had to go ATAL. Love me some Mayer every now and then, though.

[PunkDrums182]

this is way closer than i thought it'd be, went with ATAL.

[bhsbfood]

atal!
john mayers MUSIC sucks hes a good artist though

[SeanEBoy2686]

it's all came down to guitar for me on this one. Mayer.

[live.]

So so so difficult. Had to go with JM, but ATAL are incredible.

[Keagan Ilvonen]

As Tall As Lions as much as I love John.

[what_ever]

john mayer should not lose

[nickstetina]

Surprised this is so close. I thoroughly enjoy both, but JM a little more for me...ATAL fans representin though

[onthefringe]

i thoroughly enjoyed continuum.

[Broden Terry]

I voted for Mayer. I haven't heard a lot of As Tall As Lions to be honest.

[ashiex3]

I love ATAL, but I went with John Mayer.

[Spenny]

Atal

[katieissweet]

Both are incredible, but I went with As Tall As Lions.

[foisol]

http://www.bestweekever.tv/bwe/images/2008/03/MAYER%20boratSUIT2.jpg

[Mike Kraft]

As Tall As Lions. Lyrics have more meaning to me and they always put on a great, intimate show.

[mxpxjf]

John Mayer owns all. Never heard of the other band...

[Ryzenfall]

I feel bad for As Tall As Lions. I'm a huge fan of theirs, but it's The Mayer by a landslide.

[notoaststereo]

john mayer

[lucygray]

John Mayer

[WFUJerseyJon]

John Mayer easily. In addition to his ridiculous talent as a musician the guy is witty as fuck.

[Schmidty Says]

Can't get in to ATAL, but I love me some John Mayer.

[Drew Beringer]

John Mayer has infinite more talent ATAL.

[s.t.e.v.e.n.]

No question. John.

[desipunk7]

Hard one...but I went with JM

[dustyfloors]

Johnny boy wins this one.

[Co and Ca]

As Tall as Lions!

[spunkmastaflex]

JM due to his overall singles

[midtown4657]

John Mayer fucking rules.

[Undue Noise]

Mayer.

[Analog Rebellion]

John Mayer has infinite more talent ATAL.
He has more talent then a significant percentage of people in the world, haha. I didn't fully appreciate him until I listened to his good music (I don't like his pop stuff). When I listen to him play guitar, there are times when I just open my mouth and say "What.... the..... ..... .... fuckk.... .. .....".

[I'm DC]

Mayer. He is a funny dude

[Drew Beringer]

He has more talent then a significant percentage of people in the world, haha. I didn't fully appreciate him until I listened to his good music (I don't like his pop stuff). When I listen to him play guitar, there are times when I just open my mouth and say "What.... the..... ..... .... fuckk.... .. .....".
I saw him live like 5 years ago, and he is phenomenal on guitar.

[TalkShowsOnMute]

Gotta be John Mayer.

[Bobby Tucker]

This "March Mayhem" should have had some kind of seeding - then we could see both these great artists in the Final Four.
Not saying both of these artists aren't great. But on this website? Neither of these acts will get much farther, let alone to the Final Four. Seeding or not, Brand New, Blink, Say Anything, and JEW/FOB are your last four on this site...

[dejadevilgod]

as tall as lions.

[overdrive91]

john mayer is godly.

[Armor42]

I can't believe people are voting for Mayer. ATAL all the way

[artistanonymous]

While John Mayer is phenomenal at what he does, ATAL is a completely mind blowing experience when you see them live and listen to them in a quiet room and that alone puts them above John for me.

[emkvetwin]

ATAL, because John Mayer is not a band.

Mayer

[anthonydarko]

John Mayer, the man has written some pretty awesome songs.

[Imperfektion]

John Mayer is a music god.

[ChrisCTL]

AsTallAsLions on this one.

[punklet2101]

As Tall As Lions.

[Formatfun]

I voted for John Mayer, I think he's too good to go out the first round.

[Yagami]

Not saying both of these artists aren't great. But on this website? Neither of these acts will get much farther, let alone to the Final Four. Seeding or not, Brand New, Blink, Say Anything, and JEW/FOB are your last four on this site...

Not if Four Year Strong/30 Seconds To Mars/Arcade Fire gather all their fans to register and unjustly assfuck those bands in the competition.

[Galedeep]

As Tall As Lions, easily. Mayer makes me laugh, but I don't really dig him as a musician, whereas ATAL are heaven personified.

[batmannj]

ATAL, even though I believe Mayer is supremely talented.

[Troggy]

Who the heck is As Tall as Lions???

John Mayer is awesome, if he doesn't win, for shame.

[trappedintime]

John Mayer hands down.

[RonStoppable]

John Mayer. Just flat-out talented.

[doyoulikecoffee]

ATAL no doubt.

[Daniel Thompson]

christ. i really love as tall as lions. when i go to work they have a john mayer DVD playing in the video game cases and every time i walk by, i get mesmerized. I think I gotta go with Mayer.

[topher465]

Maybe I'm just tired is better than any john mayer song

[SteffRyanFail]

John Mayer is alright.
But why isn't ATAL winning this?

[phoenixinflames]

Mayer is a fantastic songwriter, an AWESOME guitar player, and a down-to-earth human being. Had to go with him.

[TheOtherAndrew]

Mayer is a fantastic instrumentalist and has a great voice, but I've never been crazy on his discography. As Tall as Lions gets it.

[RonStoppable]

John Mayer is alright.
But why isn't ATAL winning this?
Because more people, at this point, have voted for John Mayer.

[mutualaddiction]

Maybe I shouldn't be so surprised to see all the Mayer love, but I kinda am. He seems like a cool guy, and is definitely talented, I just don't care for his style of music.

[fadedmemories]

Mayer

[Ishbalan]

Well, John Mayer is John Mayer so...




As Tall As Lions.

[TheBestBet]

Atal

[n1asfan]

John Mayer

Nice avatar :)

[hydraulicheart]

As Tall As Lions. I can't say I have a John Mayer poster on my wall; he never did much for me.

[tonighttonight0]

As Tall As Lions, it shouldn't even be a contest...

[jimjam32]

kidding me? mayer for sure.

[MADSTA]

I'm not too familiar with As Tall As Lions, but last.fm keeps reccomending them to me....
I love John Mayer.

[littlebeav]

I don't understand how some of these polls are even competition. Mayer should be annihilating this. He's better, his discography is bigger, his fame is bigger, and his influence is wider reaching. Give it up retards.

[SteffRyanFail]

Because more people, at this point, have voted for John Mayer.
Thank you for clearing that up.

[ManicanParty49]

I've tried to get into ATAL, and I just can't seem to do it. So, my vote went to John.

[Bloodsucker II]

as tall as lions for sure

[Silver Bullets]

ATAL canNOT be losing

[caress me down]

John Mayer is one of the best guitarists of our time. My vote definitely goes for him.

[Digitalcursive]

As Tall As Lions all the way

[ZachMadeMeOdd]

This is an upset. As Tall As Lions is amazing and I don't understand why mayer is even considered. Didn't even know anyone liked his music.

[HorizonsMech]

Musically, As Tall As Lions has much more going for them. But John Mayer is a funny guy. Especially that time he dressed up in a bear suit and went out into the crowds gathering outside the venue of one of his shows and started making fun of them for going to a John Mayer concert. Priceless.

Still. Went with As Tall As Lions.

[stonecoldfox]

really want to say as tall as lions...but mayer is so damn good. Amazing guitar player

[Pat k]

I have no idea what As Tall As Lions is. John Mayer would probably kick their ass anyway.

[c_rob2700]

Neither. Don't see either of these bands making it out of the second round

[Troggy]

Go Johnny Go!

[sargentlgfuad]

i probably should listen to more Mayer, but i just say ATAL and they are amazing in my eyes.

[Dirge07]

Both awesome, but John's definitely at a higher level.

[ShimmerAndSpill]

Interesting match up. I got annoyed with Mayer over the last few years, although I really enjoyed Continuum. ATAL self-titled is one of my favorite albums, so had to go with them.

[&IllBeTheReason]

I'm very suprised by this poll.

[owiseone35]

Not if Four Year Strong/30 Seconds To Mars/Arcade Fire gather all their fans to register and unjustly assfuck those bands in the competition.

Wow, I kinda take offense to this putting the Arcade Fire in the same sentence with those other two bands is a disgrace. I may be the only one on this website who likes Arcade Fire but they deserve to get past first round. But i agree 1 post sign ins are pretty homo.

[zubinmoosa]

Not really a fan of either. I'm about to check out ATAL, and I've heard great things about them, so they get my vote.

[11:11]

This was almost difficult. Mayer.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Wouldn't call myself a fan of either but don't dislike them. Guess I prefer Mayer.

[myantiyou]

mayer, easy.