ok this may be ludicrous poll but...

[selftitled85]

these two center fielders have made some of the greatest catches known to man. i was just wondering who you would rather have in center for you...

[mat1419]

i see the logic of the poll...but this is such a no brainer...and on top of that you throw in what they do at the plate and it's not even the same league

[weezer182]

edmonds better not get a vote

[selftitled85]

i dunno it just seems mays was an amazing outfielder but some of the plays edmonds makes no one else could ever do. plus he covers more ground then any outfielder in the game.

[somethingyellow]

i even think (or hope) caleb will vote mays