AbsolutePunk.net

AbsolutePunk.net (http://www.absolutepunk.net/forum.php)
-  News (http://www.absolutepunk.net/forumdisplay.php?f=165)
  -  The Starting Line on American Idol (http://www.absolutepunk.net/showthread.php?t=2211492)

mbao 03/10/11 06:51 PM

Great for TSL.

Edit: Yep, it was terrible. The group stuff on Idol is always bad.

I am Mick 03/10/11 06:52 PM

Kenny Vasoli sings better 13 of the "best singers" in America.

handlikesecret 03/10/11 06:56 PM

holy Ford!

eriatarka24 03/10/11 06:57 PM

okay i was wrong
it was from santi


....lolololol @ the description

the a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a is just so off.

eriatarka24 03/10/11 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe DeAndrea (Post 86395201)
Shoulda used Bedroom Talk.

by any chance do you or anyone else know who chooses the songs that are used on the show (during auditions I know Say Anything and Jack's Mannequin have been played) and in these Ford Commercials?

good choice of bands but no, they don't know how to cover haha

xdrummerxdudex 03/10/11 07:02 PM

one of my favorite songs off BOATS

Joe DeAndrea 03/10/11 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Castaway01 (Post 86397872)
by any chance do you or anyone else know who chooses the songs that are used on the show (during auditions I know Say Anything and Jack's Mannequin have been played) and in these Ford Commercials?

good choice of bands but no, they don't know how to cover haha

Probably a combination of the label and show producers maybe but I have no idea. The band apparently didn't know either heh.

summabee 03/10/11 07:06 PM

Wow. Can't wait to see this. The Academy Is... one was horrible but go TSL!

TheBigDirty182 03/10/11 07:07 PM

sounded like shit but good for them

trojanick 03/10/11 07:11 PM

Haha the country guy mentioned he had never heard it before but now it was stuck in his head.

Awesome for TSL.

Short-Lived 03/10/11 07:14 PM

Wow....just like the show, god awful.

swimbearswim 03/10/11 07:16 PM

That's some corny shit.

ari telescope 03/10/11 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lirr168 (Post 86395041)
Hideous cover, but it's awesome that TSL is finally getting the exposure they deserve.

It's not though, no where does it say who the original artist was. All American Idol fans who don't know TSL (I'd say a good 98% of them total) just think The World is an AI original.


Am I the only one really ridiculously annoyed with this? They could have at least given credit, especially for such a horrendous job that paid no homage at all.

rhendershott 03/10/11 07:27 PM

this isn't weird at all.

spiffa0 03/10/11 07:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by I am Mick (Post 86397461)
Kenny Vasoli sings better 13 of the "best singers" in America.

Collectively yes but I'd take at least half the singers on Idol this season over Vasoli

personLman 03/10/11 07:33 PM

I can't believe this, it's sooooo awesome! I mean, they don't hold a candle to TSL but it's still amazing that they used this song.

Overpass 03/10/11 07:34 PM

That sounded so Disney like it almost hurt.

irthesteve 03/10/11 07:35 PM

THIS IS FUCKING WEIRD

probably the strangest thing i have seen in a while

jm_ab86 03/10/11 07:35 PM

Probably my least favorite TSL song. Nevertheless, it makes me happy to think of the royalties they are receiving from this. I like it when good bands make money.

Jack's Sound K 03/10/11 07:35 PM

whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat... i stopped watching ai years ago, but do they actually do good music now?

Alison1488 03/10/11 07:37 PM

This is amazing! Not the cover, but the fact that they used a TSL song. And of course TSL doesn't get an ounce of credit on that commercial, considering it's their song.

redfalcon431 03/10/11 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alison1488 (Post 86400172)
This is amazing! Not the cover, but the fact that they used a TSL song. And of course TSL doesn't get an ounce of credit on that commercial, considering it's their song.

Yeah i thought that it was messed up that it doesn't even say The Starting Line anywhere on it

JamesBond 03/10/11 07:50 PM

that should be some serious publicity

TheGoodnightMoon 03/10/11 07:51 PM

They sucked all the life out of this song and crapped out nothing but cheese. Good for TSL though.

Chalie22 03/10/11 07:53 PM

I was wondering if the band saw a paycheck come their way since they decided to use it for a commerical

ocdrum182tb 03/10/11 07:56 PM

cha ching for T$L.

aradiantsunrise 03/10/11 07:57 PM

Good for TSL.

p93 03/10/11 08:02 PM

So, what are the odds anyone in the band got a dime for this?

BigAl 03/10/11 08:08 PM

I hope Kenny and the gents get a big fat cheque for this.

fanberlinboy 03/10/11 08:10 PM

It sucked, but I freaked out when it started playing.

ari telescope 03/10/11 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alison1488 (Post 86400172)
This is amazing! Not the cover, but the fact that they used a TSL song. And of course TSL doesn't get an ounce of credit on that commercial, considering it's their song.

My gosh, I was the only other person to say this and I have no idea why.l Everyone's all "Oh shit good for them, they get so much publicity!" ummm no, all the dumb Idol fans who don't know TSL just think this is an American Idol original.

People here are backwards!

Joe DeAndrea 03/10/11 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by p93 (Post 86401581)
So, what are the odds anyone in the band got a dime for this?


The only dime they got from this would be the one they may have found in their couch while seeing it on TV. Anything probably just went to Geffen.

Debut_Fin 03/10/11 08:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bang.bang.BANG! (Post 86396071)
so gay.... tsl rules though


I must have missed the gay part because to me it just sounded like a bad cover

p93 03/10/11 08:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe DeAndrea (Post 86402292)
The only dime they got from this would be the one they may have found in their couch while seeing it on TV. Anything probably just went to Geffen.

That was my thinking exactly. Don't know why people think this is actually a good thing for TSL. Sure, it's their song, but who knows that besides people who know it already?

fanberlinboy 03/10/11 08:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ocdrum182tb (Post 86401241)
cha ching for T$L.

They are inspired by the dollar sign after all.

sodamnclever 03/10/11 08:21 PM

This reminds me of when they did the Academy Is last year. So random, but great for the bands.

friskycurtain 03/10/11 08:23 PM

Bizarre.

xrider105 03/10/11 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lirr168 (Post 86395041)
Hideous cover, but it's awesome that TSL is finally getting the exposure they deserve.

This. How did "Island" never get huge? Fucking record label.

TSLROCKS 03/10/11 08:27 PM

Absolutely horrid cover but cool nonetheless. Hope they come back soon

Jamos4184 03/10/11 08:28 PM

Wait, American Idol, or Kidz Bop??

nonohjohn 03/10/11 08:28 PM

i heard this come on in the other room and was like "wtf?" haha.

probably never gonna look at that song the same way again though... they made it so cheesy.

TSLROCKS 03/10/11 08:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobby runs (Post 86395792)
Nothing beats the demo version though.


*fixed

Agreed. Demo version is better

Lirr168 03/10/11 08:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ari telescope (Post 86399382)
It's not though, no where does it say who the original artist was. All American Idol fans who don't know TSL (I'd say a good 98% of them total) just think The World is an AI original.


Am I the only one really ridiculously annoyed with this? They could have at least given credit, especially for such a horrendous job that paid no homage at all.


You make a really good point. In fact, when "What You Want" got used in some cable commercials, at least they got mention in the corner of the screen; this is kind of b.s. Hopefully some people liked it enough to track down the lyrics or something.

Quote:

Originally Posted by xrider105 (Post 86402921)
This. How did "Island" never get huge? Fucking record label.


Agreed. It had huge potential as a summer song and Virgin at least initially seemed like a great fit. It's a real shame that they got screwed by another label.

Imperfektion 03/10/11 08:46 PM

This is like adult version of Kids Bop.

UnderclasHero 03/10/11 08:47 PM

Awesome. Surprised they didnt show the actual name, and band at the end.

MALKiiN 03/10/11 08:48 PM

they still make this show? who watches it

brenByah 03/10/11 09:03 PM

They butchered that...

absolutebutthol 03/10/11 09:04 PM

Very humbling for the band. This is awesome. Makes me wanna stick cheetos up my butt, and fart them out :)

koss7129 03/10/11 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ari telescope (Post 86399382)
It's not though, no where does it say who the original artist was. All American Idol fans who don't know TSL (I'd say a good 98% of them total) just think The World is an AI original.


Am I the only one really ridiculously annoyed with this? They could have at least given credit, especially for such a horrendous job that paid no homage at all.

this is exactly what i was thinking, there's no mention of them at all, the album cover is the american idol one and the text says American Idol's The World, and no like original artist mention

10 years from now someone will think that TSL covered that american idol song

lyrical_lie777 03/10/11 09:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Imperfektion (Post 86403731)
This is like adult version of Kids Bop.

oh god i thought the same thing.

but yes its sad that they didn't get anything written about the fact that its a cover.