AbsolutePunk.net

AbsolutePunk.net (http://www.absolutepunk.net/forum.php)
-  News (http://www.absolutepunk.net/forumdisplay.php?f=165)
  -  The Dropkick Murphys Respond to Republican Using Their Song (http://www.absolutepunk.net/showthread.php?t=2747122)

Jason Tate 05/14/12 09:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UnderMyDreams (Post 107987562)
That would depend on the contract.

Virtually all bands have some say in their publishing and licensing agreements to where songs can be publicly performed, or sold, etc. Most politicians don't even try and get the rights.

iamsoindie 05/14/12 09:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ...atfirstsight (Post 107963112)
This is so unbelievably stupid. I guess I can't appreciate Childish Gambino/Donald Glover because he's black and I'm white... have any Adam Lambert songs on my iPhone because he's gay and I'm straight.... or listen to any number of atheist/agnostic artists because I'm not.

Bottom line is this: everyone who listens to the same song will take away something different, some may be really surprising. For an artist to say: "You're not allowed to enjoy our music because you are an (fill in the blank)" is ridiculous.

Are you actually comparing one's race or sexuality with the campaigning of one's political stance? This makes no sense.

The Dropkick Murphys have every right to be upset. They want nothing to do with this guy's campaign and I'm sure they would not appreciate people connecting their band and ethos to Fitzgerald.

How's this for an analogy: Would you say that Michael Stipe would have the right to be upset if a politician was using an R.E.M. song to introduce his campaign, and this politician was adamantly against homosexual rights? To be a tad more topical, would Laura Jane Grace (formerly Tom Gabel) have the right to be upset if an Against Me! song was used by a politician that slandered transgenders? These aren't even great examples, but I hope (I really, really hope) you get the point.

anthonydarko 05/14/12 09:24 PM

Why is it hard for people to understand that some people don't want their art being used for means that they are against?

Sloth7 05/14/12 09:26 PM

All this political mumbo jumbo is just taking attention away from the P.O.D. news post.

Ailite 05/14/12 09:28 PM

Good for the DKM's.

underthetalking 05/14/12 09:31 PM

But it's okay for them to say ****** in a promo...

prospekt 05/14/12 09:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CellarGhosts (Post 107986012)
hahahahahah right okay so bands have no say in who gets to use their music that they created if they see it as something that conflicts with their interests. God you're fucking stupid.


Did you read my post stupid kid?

I said they can say it, but it doesn't mean people will give a shit. You're acting as if DKM's opinion is federal law over who can play their music or not.

anthonydarko 05/14/12 09:43 PM

Prospekt calling someone a stupid kid, talk about irony.

hurleyintrntinl 05/14/12 10:02 PM

Seems a simple enough thing...

Politics aside, the band doesn't want their song being used by Scott Walker/ his campaign. This request can easily be honored and I'm sure the campaign will find another walk-on song for Mr. Walker (or face further action by the band and their label).

That being said, the name-calling in this thread is embarrassing. Simply because someone expresses an opinion of their own does not make them stupid/a moron/whatever else one might be tempted to call a person with a different opinion than one's own. I'm not saying I haven't been guilty of this in the past, but a little more class in the replies wouldn't hurt anybody. Just my two cents.

anthonydarko 05/14/12 10:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hurleyintrntinl (Post 107989482)
Seems a simple enough thing...

Politics aside, the band doesn't want their song being used by Scott Walker/ his campaign. This request can easily be honored and I'm sure the campaign will find another walk-on song for Mr. Walker (or face further action by the band and their label).

That being said, the name-calling in this thread is embarrassing. Simply because someone expresses an opinion of their own does not make them stupid/a moron/whatever else one might be tempted to call a person with a different opinion than one's own. I'm not saying I haven't been guilty of this in the past, but a little more class in the replies wouldn't hurt anybody. Just my two cents.


This is pretty much how the front page has always been, class does not exist here.

contra11mundum 05/14/12 10:14 PM

But seriously though... Time of Your Life....Green Day....what's up with that?

i like apples 05/14/12 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by prospekt (Post 107988482)
Did you read my post stupid kid?

I said they can say it, but it doesn't mean people will give a shit. You're acting as if DKM's opinion is federal law over who can play their music or not.

This thread is hilarious. This has happened a million times, artists not wanting people of opposite political standpoints using their music to promote a cause they are against. They have every right to bitch and moan. And YES, they can do something about it.

rollerman4221 05/14/12 10:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jason Tate (Post 107969262)
New fact: If the thread has kidinthebushes or prospekt in it ... it's gonna be full of stupid posts.

dont forget cwhit or however its spelled

slimfenix182 05/14/12 11:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hurleyintrntinl (Post 107989482)
Seems a simple enough thing...

Politics aside, the band doesn't want their song being used by Scott Walker/ his campaign. This request can easily be honored and I'm sure the campaign will find another walk-on song for Mr. Walker (or face further action by the band and their label).

That being said, the name-calling in this thread is embarrassing. Simply because someone expresses an opinion of their own does not make them stupid/a moron/whatever else one might be tempted to call a person with a different opinion than one's own. I'm not saying I haven't been guilty of this in the past, but a little more class in the replies wouldn't hurt anybody. Just my two cents.


Thank you. I once misread a figure about album sales and was immediately called an idiot. I love when you see a news post that shouldn't have as many replies as it does, and you can immediately assume two (at least) internet tough guys are at war in said thread... Ugh.

randys950 05/15/12 12:26 AM

I never heard the song, is it politically driven towards being a democrat? if not, then it's stupid to bitch about someone liking one's music. he's probably just chasing after attention.