I registered exactly for this thread.
Yes it's not kingdoms, but I found that out after their single releases. That was really disappointing. And their singles aren't the stand out songs.
I Am Not A Rockstar uninspired lyrics? Are you sure you got the right album? It's a dam well written satire song of this fake Rockstar life. It's a funny song. I know it's not the Broadway we love, but it still leaves me singing to the song. ESPECIALLY Party at Sean's House, how the hell do you not song along to ” It's 4 AM and I'm the only one sober?”
Again it's not the post hardcore broadway we were introduced to, but this is a very solid album
I'm glad you like the album as a whole, but it just wasn't for me. I'm sure that "Party at Sean's House" will appeal to some people, like you, but for me it was just annoying. I can see how people can find the song catchy, but I didn't; I found it quite irritating actually. The album is not as unique nor as dynamic as Kingdoms. Also, like I said in my review, I wouldn't have cared that Broadway had changed their sound, but many of the songs, for me, are just not good. This is just a generic pop-punk album at best. I am glad you liked it though because Broadway definitely deserves some recognition, just not for this album. To me, this isn't the Broadway people should be listening to; but to each his own. Thanks for reading my review either way!