I'm an old TSL fan. With that said I do love vacationer. But I really want a new tsl album in vein of say it like you mean it. SLYM is such a great album, and it's not just because of nostalgia. I love it because it's just a great straight up pop punk album. Super catchy, and most of the songs are FAST and just flat out rock.
I really hope that if they do another album it is just a fast punk type album. I don't even listen to newer music in the pop punk genre but I would be stoked beyond belief if The Starting Line could write another classic!
I love Vacationer, won't miss them any time they come through town and can't wait for new music. With that said, I'd still kill for new music from The Starting Line, but I don't really have much confidence that it will ever happen. I just hope that if it does, it's not rushed. I wasn't impressed with "Luck" at all.