great read. looking forward to more form this column. I would rather see a band suck live and own it...then fake it with backing tracks. If I wanted to see musicians fake it, I could see any number of top 40 artists live. I remember back in 2003 when the used were on tour. Bert's vocals were so piss poor live...but it was still bad ass. Same with seeing buddy from senses fail back in the day. But the rawness of it all made up for the lack of perfection. And as for pro sports, I think they need to crack down further. Its not fair to the real athletes that train clean. Maybe there should be a separate league for cheaters...people would pay to see home runs that go 500+ feet. Just as while pretty much everything on the radio would be fake live...they still sell out arenas.
I worked a show a while back and they had a sound guy with his own mixing board on the side of the stage.
Although there was some vocal performance, the guitars/bass as well as some of the vocals were tracked.
It was embarrassing to see kids going so crazy for such sham artists.
I'm not doubting Tyler Carter's abilities, as he's a fantastic singer and I'm sure the rest of the band are good in their own right, but how fucking lazy and careless do you have to be to track your songs live?
Ridiculous, if you ask me...but maybe I'm a purist.
That is from the 10 year anniversary live DVD and nothing was replaced on that recording. In fact, since we played our entire discography up to that point we made some mistakes and that's why we had to pick and choose which songs because some guitars were a bit out of tune or vocals way off. However, the mixer did put effects on things in post and yes it sounds to me like he used melodyne and compression and maybe even overdrive. I don't know what he did but I think a live record is different than a live show since it will be played over and over repetitively.