[ThisIsNotDan]

Originally Posted by Protested Hero

I didn't forget about the album at all and I listen to it a ton. I love it. It's no IARB, but did anyone ever think it would be, haha?

true, although if it had come right after IARB it would definetly be a letdown. anything after IDOTG just looks amazing in comparison though haha

[*crying stars*]

I must be one of the very few that loves IDOTG.

[Charles777]

I think IDOTG is their best album.

[SincerelyMe]

Originally Posted by *crying stars*

I must be one of the very few that loves IDOTG.

Agreed.

[IamTheINDUSTRY]

In it's defense idotg would be a lot better as a 12 or 13 song album.

[TheSkyline]

Originally Posted by *crying stars*

I must be one of the very few that loves IDOTG.

Nope, I do too.

Originally Posted by Charles777

I think IDOTG is their best album.

But, not sure about that.

[drudo182]

Yeah, cut Defense down and it's a good album.

...Is A Real Boy is still my fav.

[sophos34]

I havent given in defense a full listen yet but IARB is too good to be topped. Album is phenomenal, I take back what I said about it being over rated

[captainamazing4]

i still enjoy this album very much

[tawtaw]

I wouldn't take any tracks off of IDotG. I like them all to some degree.

[mrnegativezero]

I can't compare this album to the others. It's really good and all, but it's so different than the others.

[Broclee]

Originally Posted by mrnegativezero

I can't compare this album to the others. It's really good and all, but it's so different than the others.

I think in that aspect it's a lot like FAD or IOH from Fall Out Boy.

[mrnegativezero]

Originally Posted by Broclee

I think in that aspect it's a lot like FAD or IOH from Fall Out Boy.

Considering that I started to get into them between Infinity on High and Folie à Deux, and as a result know those albums better than From Under the Cork Tree or Take This To Grave, I'll just take your word for it.

[Broclee]

Originally Posted by mrnegativezero

Considering that I started to get into them between Infinity on High and Folie à Deux, and as a result know those albums better than From Under the Cork Tree or Take This To Grave, I'll just take your word for it.

Haha, understandable. I mean, going from the pretty straight-forward pop punk sounds on TTTYG and FUCT to the much more produced and pop-oriented sound on IOH and FAD was pretty drastic, and it's really polarized a lot of fans. I feel like this album, or at least Say Anything in general, have done the same. ...Is A Real Boy is pretty generally loved, and they've polarized since then by branching out and trying new things.