Album Review
Athletics - Why Aren't I Home? Album Cover

Athletics - Why Aren't I Home?

Reviewed by
Athletics - Why Aren't I Home
Record Label: Deep Elm
Release Date: Oct. 22, 2010
This review was written by an AP.net staff member.
Athletics is an Asbury Park post-rock quintet.

How is it?
Scary good. Post-rock is a vast and deep genre that often brings together some of the best minds in music few people are talking about. Asbury Park's Athletics are a shining example of just how true that is. Album opener, "Why Aren't I Home?," begins with skittering guitar work, a hypnotic rhythm section and a visceral, all-consuming and undeniably arresting effort thats quite honestly as triumphant as any post-rock selection released this year. That being said, beginning the album with the strongest track is never the best of ideas, and in many ways, the rest of Why Aren't I Home? tries to match the transcendence of the title track.

While it's a valiant effort, only a couple tracks come anywhere close.

"See You On the Other Side" is snappy, jittery and hard-charging. There's fractious, antic moments throughout and a cornucopia of naunces that help make "See You On the Other Side," stand out. The vernal and quieter, "Fairview," is ruminative and meditative and opens like a prayer, with guitars that genuflect gracefully. "Jordan" abandons the post-rock formula and employs vocals in a composition that sounds eerily similar to something AP darling Jesse Lacey might have written. Halfway through the song collapses on top of itself and becomes a towering tormented slab of rock ferocity.

The muted and muffled "Speaking for Everyone" is distant and feels horribly like filler. Ambient, celestial and inviting it serves its purpose well, but ostensibly serves as a bridge between "Jordan," and sixth track "I Am Withdrawal" The latter features a glowing mist of guitars, bellowing vocals (yes, vocals) and thick heavy drums. Searing guitar work weaves and bobs spider-like towards the song's conclusion and a towering guitar solo in the latter half help make the song arguably one of the disc's best. "Lullaby" is frightening, alienating and downright possessed. Terrorizing vocals help make the song that much more surprising.

"August," serves as filler, while "It's Night It's Enough," is a placid, pretty and plaintive composition that bursts into a cavalcade of guitars, all-consuming drums and thumping bass. Anchored by a powerhouse finish, lush dynamics and some of the disc's best guitarwork, "It's Night, It's Enough," is the point at where the listener can't help but think "Fuck, this band can bring it." "Affliction" is a wintry piano composition that probably could have been left off and only serves as a respite and a calming segue for the titanic, agressive and full- throttle energy of "The Cost of Living."

When the proverbial needle finally stops the end result is a concussive, draining and visceral tour-de-force that's as inspired, emotional and impacting as any post- rock disc released this year. Score another one for Deep Elm.

Track Listing 1. Why Aren't I Home?
2. See You On the Other Side
3. Fairview
4. Jordan
5. Speaking for Everyone
6. I Am Withdrawal
7. Lullaby
8. August
9. It's Night, It's Enough
10. Affliction
11. The Cost of Living

Recommended If You Like Instrumental versions of Jimmy Eat World, Brand New and Thrice

Find Them Here Myspace
Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 17
10:17 AM on 11/23/10
Playfully witty sign-off
User Info.
PetitnaindesÎles's Avatar
Album is fantastic, i do like the EP version of I Am Withdrawal better though.
10:41 AM on 11/23/10
Matthew Tsai
Born and raised
User Info.
Matthew Tsai's Avatar
Great review Greg. I love this album.
01:34 PM on 11/23/10
don't ask
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
So so so so so good. Deep Elm is possibly the best label out there.
03:11 PM on 11/23/10
Gregory Robson
Under Rug Swept
User Info.
Gregory Robson's Avatar
So so so so so good. Deep Elm is possibly the best label out there.
I won't disagree with that at all.
08:16 PM on 11/23/10
Sleep underground tonight...
User Info.
Romancebled's Avatar
This band is excellent. One of my new favorites this year.
08:18 PM on 11/23/10
dawn afterglow
Registered User
User Info.
dawn afterglow's Avatar
Love this album.
08:59 PM on 11/23/10
Registered User
User Info.
focustempochamp's Avatar
great dudes, great album.
09:36 PM on 11/25/10
Regular Member
User Info.
DriftingNAndOut's Avatar
I disagree about August. It's the best track on this album. Also, no Moving Mountains in RIYL?
09:49 AM on 11/27/10
User Info.
Bruycker's Avatar
indeed. This reminds me of Moving Mountains
01:57 PM on 11/29/10
User Info.
onautolux's Avatar
02:32 PM on 12/07/10
destination: beautiful
User Info.
boscorelli's Avatar
reminds me more of treos then any of the bands you listed. can't decide if i like the album or not.
08:30 AM on 12/08/10
Stage three has begun.
User Info.
SLoT's Avatar
I heard this yesterday for the first time. I liked it quite a bit, and will be giving it more listens soon... nice review as well.
06:17 AM on 12/13/10
Regular Member
User Info.
DriftingNAndOut's Avatar
Album is fantastic, i do like the EP version of I Am Withdrawal better though.
Where can I get this EP?
04:54 PM on 01/22/11
Registered User
User Info.
WellImCool's Avatar
Can't stop listening to this cd. Too amazing.

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate