[M.Lee]

Holy LOL @ anyone putting Eli in the top 10.

[KidRobot]

itt: everyone overrates Matt Ryan.

[ellie117]

Originally Posted by M.Lee

Holy LOL @ anyone putting Eli in the top 10.

Thank you, I'm glad someone else laughed along with me.

[M.Lee]

Originally Posted by ellie117

Thank you, I'm glad someone else laughed along with me.

The funny thing is I don't even think it's Giants fans because they know better.

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

itt: everyone overrates Matt Ryan.

who would you put above him?

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by ellie117

Thank you, I'm glad someone else laughed along with me.

Originally Posted by M.Lee

Holy LOL @ anyone putting Eli in the top 10.

11th in comp %
6th in yards
4th in tds
5th in passer rating.

yeah, that guy sucks.

[M.Lee]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

11th in comp %
6th in yards
4th in tds
5th in passer rating.

yeah, that guy sucks.

OP already said it's not about just this year. Eli led the league in INTs last year with the best offensive line (sacks-wise). I could go on but I really, really don't think I need to explain this to most people in this thread.

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

who would you put above him?

This year?

Eli, Stafford, Vick, Cassel to name a few.

[kyle is hk]

I don't like Eli Manning either but the guy has always performed well

If we were ranking ability to give a good interview of star in a commercial, I'd rank him 32.

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

This year?

Eli, Stafford, Vick, Cassel to name a few.

not just based on the five games played this year.

EDIT: and cassel?? what?

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by M.Lee

OP already said it's not about just this year. Eli led the league in INTs last year with the best offensive line (sacks-wise). I could go on but I really, really don't think I need to explain this to most people in this thread.

how many on that list have better stats currently and a ring to boot? Find me 10.

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

not just based on the five games played this year.

I'd still probably take those 4 over Ryan anyway. Definitely Eli and Stafford (when healthy) at least

[spiffa0]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

how many on that list have better stats currently and a ring to boot? Find me 10.

Trent Dilfer has a ring. Guess he's one of the best too

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

I'd still probably take those 4 over Ryan anyway. Definitely Eli and Stafford (when healthy) at least

eh, disagree. stafford showed promise before this year, but i'm not ready to say he's better than ryan based off five games. eli throws way too many picks/makes way too many dumb mistakes. cassel is... cassel. there's a reason every chiefs fan on this site (both of them?) despise cassel and are dying to win the suck for luck campaign.

[M.Lee]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

how many on that list have better stats currently and a ring to boot? Find me 10.

If you're talking about starting QBs with a ring, Eli is still last. Hope that helps you out.