Need some opinions...
I'm in a startup cash keeper league and I can keep one player from my 2011 roster.
I'll lose the draft pick for the player that I decide to keep - two rounds up from their original draft slot. So, I took AJ Green in the fifth round in 2011, I'll lose my third rounder in 2012.
My team finished fourth out of twelve, but the top of my draft didn't have much to do with it. I traded two of them (Steven Jackson and Vincent Jackson), and my first selection was Calvin Johnson.
Not sure if I want to keep Megatron, because I might able to land a top back or quarterback in the first round if I decide against keeping him.
The league is PPR. 10 rushing yards = 1 pt and 10 receiving yards = 1 pt.
tl;dr: I'm deciding between Calvin Johnson (lose my first rounder), AJ Green (lose my third rounder), or Reggie Bush (lose my fifth rounder).
I'd easily keep Calvin Johnson....no questions. Since you probably won't know who's back in to be drafted for this year, he'd easily be a first round pick and unless you have someone in mind that you just can't live without, keep him.