I read the article some days ago, and I thought it was pretty favorable to them.
Guess I have to re-read it to make sure.
EDIT: I stand by what I said.
"Grizzly Bear’s songs rev without going anywhere."
"There is a nearly suffocating fussiness in this band."
"Rhythm is a frozen concern here, several orders less important than harmony."
"he, like the rest of the band, has almost zero body language"
"I left Town Hall grinding my teeth."
I think there were some positive statements, but these were not.