AbsolutePunk.net
   Username
Password
 
Album Review
Hint: Follow a reviewer to be notified when they post reviews.
Saves the Day - Stay What You Are Album Cover
Author's Rating
Vocals 8.75
Musicianship 9.25
Lyrics 9.25
Production 9
Creativity 9.5
Lasting Value 9.5
Reviewer Tilt 9.5
Final Verdict: 93%
Member Ratings
Vocals 8.23
Musicianship 7.68
Lyrics 7.98
Production 7.77
Creativity 7.77
Lasting Value 8.14
Reviewer Tilt 8.77
Average: 80%
Inside AP.net

Saves the Day - Stay What You Are

Reviewed by: SethGrandpa (08/20/09)
Saves the Day - Stay What You Are
Record Label: Vagrant
Release Date: July 10, 2001

Here goes a rendition the classic music critic gripe:

If the world was a “just” place (oh silly critics) Saves the Day would have the career of Fall Out Boy, only with way more credibility. 2001’s Stay What You Are is the most radio-ready emo album there is and it’s not even that close. It’s melodic bliss, yet somehow it just didn’t click. Saves the Day was just four years too early. The album came out in the height of pop punk’s infiltration of mainstream teen culture, and this album just didn’t fit the mold of the Blink-182s and Sum 41s of the world. But hey, as a music listener, I'd prefer that an albumbe unappreciated and great than known and unlistenable.

Atypically, the album begins with a funeral on the aptly titled “At Your Funeral.” The track is not as melancholy as one would expect, in fact, musically it’s bouncy. Like most of the songs on Stay What You Are it emotes more bitterness than sorrow. The follow-up “See You” features leadman Chris Conley at some of his lyrical best, with vivid imagery that is instantly relatable:

“My gut is burning. Won’t you find me some water?
Hey, just forget it can you bring me gasoline
and collect a couple forks, hold them three feet apart
and wait for lightning to strike to burn me up?
Cause I don’t think that I have got the stomach to
stomach calling you today.

“Cars & Calories” almost seems like a premonition listening back on it now. It’s vicious attack on the falseness of celebrity culture and the obsession with appearance is like a direct critique of people’s fascination with tabloids and “reality” TV shows like The Hills. Conley’s lyrics continue to shine on “Jukebox Breakdown,” which explores the very cool idea of what it means to be a singer through means of an extended jukebox metaphor.

The ballad “Freakish” is the kind of number the band was made to play. It’s hopelessly romantic swoonings encapsulate youthful heartache to a T. Maybe it was choosing this song to be a somewhat unconventional single that did in Stay What You Are’s chances of success, but it’s hard to buy that, because it has one of best music videos ever.

“As Your Ghost Takes Flight” and “All I’m Losing Is Me” both feature offbeat guitar parts that instantly catch the ear’s attention. “As Your Ghost…” is the most morose and angry tune on the album, as Conley sings of revenge and blood drinking (another missed opportunity, the Twilight kids would eat this up). The songs are just part of the first-class musical variety that Saves the Day’s members display throughout Stay What You Are.

With the album nearing it’s end things wind down with “Nightingale” and “This Is Not An Exit.” They are more delicate, understated tunes which gives them a bit more reflective air. It amazing more songs in the genre are not do not strive for this sound, which fits the downtrodden aesthetic so much more accurately. As Stay What You Are goes out in a glorious burst of flickering flames on “Firefly,” one could bemoan a band that had every right to make it and didn’t. But that misses the point. Saves the Day made an album the likes of which the bands that followed in their success can’t touch. That seems just enough.

Recommended If You LikeEmo; Fall Out Boy - From Under the Cork Tree; Brand New - Your Favorite Weapon
 
Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 15
10:06 PM on 08/31/09
#2
flks511
You can't be my friend
Offline
User Info.
flks511's Avatar
Great album. Average review.
07:42 AM on 09/01/09
#3
Chris Collum
Offline
User Info.
Chris Collum's Avatar
Amazing album and imo the only good one in STD discography.

The reason they didn't get huge is they followed SWYA with a string of sub par albums. By the way this album sold over 200,000 copies which is pretty good for an indie album with no radio play.
Yeah...have you ever heard of an album called Through Being Cool? And don't write off the rest of the STD catalog just because In Reverie, the album immediately after this one, wasn't amazing...
07:44 AM on 09/01/09
#4
Chris Collum
Offline
User Info.
Chris Collum's Avatar
And to the reviewer: this album deserves better.
07:44 AM on 09/01/09
#5
Chris Collum
Offline
User Info.
Chris Collum's Avatar
And to the reviewer: this album deserves better.
Sorry man I don't mean to be harsh...but come on, comparing STD to Fall Out Boy?? And they're def. more pop-punk than emo, dude...
08:12 PM on 09/01/09
#6
MXkillerPX
Registered User
Offline
User Info.
MXkillerPX's Avatar
He didn't really compare them to Fall Out Boy. He said that if the world was just, Saves the Day would have become as famous as Fall Out Boy. I happen to agree. Nice job, reviewer.

More pop punk than emo? I'm sick of all these sub-genres. Half the time there's no difference, it's just some label you put on the music.
07:14 PM on 09/02/09
#7
EndSerenading
we were born for battle
Offline
User Info.
EndSerenading's Avatar
superb record. through being cool was fantastic too but this one was just perfect. They dont make em like they used to :(
02:25 AM on 09/04/09
#8
SethGrandpa
Rock The Casbah
Offline
User Info.
SethGrandpa's Avatar
Quote:
The reason they didn't get huge is they followed SWYA with a string of sub par albums. By the way this album sold over 200,000 copies which is pretty good for an indie album with no radio play.

While I understand this, I still feel this one should have been bigger. While it moved a good number of units, the band never crossed over into any sort of mainstream relevance.

He didn't really compare them to Fall Out Boy. He said that if the world was just, Saves the Day would have become as famous as Fall Out Boy.

This.

I don't think of them as similar bands, but if played their songs to most people (not much of the AP crowd) they'd probably say the two groups sound very similar in the grand scheme of things. I used Fall Out Boy to illustrate an idea and for those a who are in need of something more familiar or currently relevant as a reference point.
03:41 PM on 09/05/09
#9
zubinmoosa
Tonight I'm Burning Star IV
Offline
User Info.
zubinmoosa's Avatar
fantastic album
06:01 AM on 09/08/09
TheInfamousAdam
Infamous since '85
Offline
User Info.
TheInfamousAdam's Avatar
hmm... I was just wearing my Saves the Day shirt yesterday and was summing up all the times I've ever heard them on the radio... NONE. WTF Through Being Cool is a top 5 favorite album ever for me. This band rocks. This album does too.
02:04 PM on 09/12/09
jordalsh
twitter.com/Jordalsh
Offline
User Info.
jordalsh's Avatar
One of my favorite albums of all time
08:13 AM on 09/14/09
stereokiller
Howdy.
Offline
User Info.
stereokiller's Avatar
one of the best records ever.

and def disagree that this is the only good one in STD discography.

this and Through Being Cool just happen to be the more accessible ones.
12:16 PM on 10/07/09
hochtk
Registered User
Offline
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
Hands down the greatest pop/punk album of all time. Also my second favorite album ever, behind The Flaming Lips' Soft Bulletin.
07:14 PM on 10/08/09
xapplexpiex
&.&
Offline
User Info.
xapplexpiex's Avatar
Honestly, this album took a while to grow on me. I've had it on repeat for the past couple days, and I can't get enough of it now. Firefly is my favorite track. Um I'm not sure I agree with your RIYL though, but nonetheless, great review!
12:11 AM on 05/31/11
sonnyboy
James Heck
Offline
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
i love listening to this album while driving to my girlfriends house. she lives in the mountains, past Auburn, Ca. just nature, a dark sky glowing with stars, and "nightingale" .... aahhhh bliss :D
Options
More From This Author
Buy the Music

NEWS, MUSIC & MORE
Search News
Release Dates
Exclusives
Best New Music
Articles
CONNECT
Submit News
Forums
Contests
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
HIDDEN TREASURES
AbsolutePunk Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Recommendations
INFORMATION
Advertising
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
FOLLOW
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
PropertyOfZack
PunkNews.org
UnderTheGun
Chorus.fm