Originally Posted by |ant|
You sir, have just described what is deathly ill about the music industry in this era. Bands who follow this system consistently fall through the cracks. I was disapointed with this review, and believed a so called "professional" reviewer could see the talent here. I am by no means dubbing this a masterpiece, but your review is ridiculous. This site is on cue about 50% of the time, but when you miss, your marksmanship is nonexistent. Giving albums like Moneen, Punchline, Rookie of the Year, and Hit the Lights all higher than 80%??? That is a shame. All of these bands in whos sound are not mutually exclusive get the nod from your reviewers. At least someone got Anathallo - Floating World right, or I would lose all faith in this sight. Also, it seems Anathallo did not follow your so called "formula to success" as stated above, and put out probably one of the most interesting and visceral listening experiences this year. Shame on you.
hmm i did write the anathallo review...weird. i back my review up 100%. it is not a good album, but if you have listened to it i would love to hear YOUR thought on it besides you ripping apart the site as a whole (we have like 8 reviewers so those tastes aren't always going to match up). Thanks for your feedback.