I'm glad to see that you bolded Full Collapse. Definitely one of my all time favorites as welll but I can't say I loved Common Existence. I mean it was good but I had expectations for it to be the greatest. Have you heard the B-sides though? I don't know why they weren't on the album. Fake Nostalgia and the Worst Vow are 2 of my favorite Thursday songs and Fake Nostalgia was even my best song of 09.