Originally Posted by SteveD

As a long time die hard fan of the band this album disappointed me to no end. I wanted to cry when I got done listening to it because I though it was that bad. Pear Of The Stars is the only real stand-out track.

While I don't agree with you about "Pearl of the Stars" being the only stand out, did you like this more than No World for Tomorrow?

Originally Posted by Thomas Nassiff

While I don't agree with you about "Pearl of the Stars" being the only stand out, did you like this more than No World for Tomorrow?

No, I though No World For Tomorrow was a great album with a lot of great tracks. No World For Tomorrow, Mother Superior, Gravemakers & Gunslingers, On The Brink. Hell I loved every track on that album, I wouldn't skip one song.

On YOTBR I would really skip most of the song, I really didn't like the album at all. I tried to I really tried to force myself to like it but it didn't happen.

i've enjoyed all of your reviews thus far.

Originally Posted by SteveD

No, I though No World For Tomorrow was a great album with a lot of great tracks. No World For Tomorrow, Mother Superior, Gravemakers & Gunslingers, On The Brink. Hell I loved every track on that album, I wouldn't skip one song.

On YOTBR I would really skip most of the song, I really didn't like the album at all. I tried to I really tried to force myself to like it but it didn't happen.

Mehh, you shouldn't have to force yourself to like anything haha. To each their own.

I do not like this album at all. Good review though. Well written

Originally Posted by Thomas Nassiff

Mehh, you shouldn't have to force yourself to like anything haha. To each their own.

I know. It sucks. I love Coheed so much and I really wanted to like it. It just didn't work for me. Same thing with Brand New Daisy I wanted to like it I just didn't. Sad Face.

No

I love Coheed but this album hasn't been doing it for me, I got to give it a few more listens been getting distracted by all the other great releases. Great review I enjoyed the perspective from someone who's not a die hard fan, allowed more objectivity, excellent job.

Honestly, this is the only positive review I've read yet of this album. Haven't really taken the time to get into Coheed, but I'm guessing this isn't the album to do it...?

great review!

I am a gigantic Coheed fanboy and have loved everything they have ever done. I fucking hate this album.

Originally Posted by Matty Ice

Honestly, this is the only positive review I've read yet of this album. Haven't really taken the time to get into Coheed, but I'm guessing this isn't the album to do it...?

No, not this album. Start with the beginning of the discography.

The production really pisses me off. I know these songs would sound awesome if they were produced better, but it's really holding Coheed back on this record. It's a shame because I love what I hear... I just can't even hear what I know is there. :/

I'm a huge Coheed fan...I liked it but wasnt sure on repeated listens when I first heard it...but after taking awhile to adjust...I loved it and play it all the time now. I think all the coheed fans just need to let to grow for awhile since it does have a different feeling from the other albums...or at least thats how i feel about it

Originally Posted by Thomas Nassiff

Thanks, I'm interested to hear what he has to say. You're all about the first-letter-of-the-first-name-followed-by-a-dash-then-another-word nicknames. I can respect that.

At least it's better than Jobin.