Woe, Is Me is a guilty pleasure. i listen to them for the vocals and the drumming, which are great. i know they arent really original, but i just like them. UABB just bothers me. 8.5 for creativity is way too high honestly. but for Woe, Is Me, i'd honestly only give them maybe a 6 for creativity.
It seems that what you're saying is due more for the fact you don't like UABB than because the scoring is way off. I'll agree that 8.5 for creativity is a little high, but it's not completely unwarranted. Danny's screams are some of the most recognizable in the genre(think of him as the Austin Carlile of deathcore/metalcore) and as a whole, these guys are incorporating more metal elements than most of their peers. Plus, Ramon is one sick drummer.