Er, what? Black Swan got a great reception and it didn't sound too close to their first two. That's why it was good actually, they started maturing.
Sorry, reception is not the appropriate word, more like attention. They've been under the radar last couple years, at Pointfest(st louis version of weenie roast) I think I recall them being one of the first bands to play, but back in 05 they were third from last. There popularity seems to be dying down, and I think the constant had some good songs, especially eye for an eye and to the burial, but imo they sound almost too much like they did during page avenue except without the "making girls scream over emo lyrics"