[Drew Beringer]

Originally Posted by DeviateRogue

Fair enough. I'm not a big statistics guy. But Faulk has a championship ring at least.

championships define teams and their greatness. When making a list of the greatest players ever, you need to throw out the Super Bowl argument.

[Drew Beringer]

anyways, glad to see Reggie in the top 10. My favorite Packer from those great mid-90s teams.

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by Chris M.

Are you loling at Gale Sayers because you feel he should be higher? 'Cause he probably should.

how do you figure? and for the record i was lolling that gale sayers is that high and davis isn't even on the list, not so much a comment on how high sayers is, but i do feel it's a bit weird to rank someone that high off two spectacular seasons.


from the nfl thread

[about3fitty]

just noticed that ed reed is on the list. dont agree with that at all

[startBBtoday]

man, deion sanders at 34 is really high

[startBBtoday]

by the same justification of gale sayers being 22, shouldn't steve young be much higher than he is? if we're completely discounting longevity for one player, how are we ranking steve young lower than troy aikman

[M.Lee]

If only Bo Jackson hadn't gotten hurt.

[domotime2]

no real issues with the list. Was DT on the list?

[tonighttonight0]

Reggie White has always been my favorite player since I was a kid. It's great to see he's #7.

[capnhook54]

Jim Kelly isn't one of the 100 greatest NFL players? All credibility gone.

[barkingincision]

kurt warner shouldn't be here... tom brady should be lower... jerry rice is the obvious top pick.

[tkamB]

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

man, deion sanders at 34 is really high

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-networ...pot-in-Top-100

[WTG]

Originally Posted by tkamB

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-networ...pot-in-Top-100

Hahahaha, I love that man.

[bobsheiskawy]

i'm going to get a lot of hate for this, but i think that once all is said and done, ben roethlisberger should and will be considered to be on the top half of this list.

[spiffa0]

Originally Posted by bobsheiskawy

i'm going to get a lot of hate for this, but i think that once all is said and done, ben roethlisberger should and will be considered to be on the top half of this list.

Completely agree and that's not just because I love the Steelers. Saying he is already on there right now is a little bit much but he definitely will be when his career is over.