I'm inclined to disagree.
I've never thought they were bad live.
The only complaint that I had, was I saw them do a headlining tour with Chiodos and Boys Night Out, and everyone came for Chiodos and just kinda stuck around for the following 2 bands. I hate it when people do that.
I saw them on that tour and they bored the shit out of me, and then they vied with Senses Fail for worst performance of Warped Tour 2006.