Which show did you go to? I went to the one here in Clifton Park/Albany, New York and people seemed to be going just as wild for Underoath as they were for The Word Alive and A Day To Remember. Close Your Eyes was actually the band that people seemed disinterested in.
I saw them in Allentown PA, people were pretty quiet for Close Your Eyes until they played "Song For the Broken" and like fifteen people and myself rushed on stage for the chant part. People were crazy for The Word Alive as well, Underoath was a buzzkill that show, then ADTR just did what they always do and didn't disappoint.