[Smash Adams]

So far I'm owning this challenge #winning

[NarcolepsySmile]

Originally Posted by FeynmanWannabe

I don't see how the idea is different: Take a publication's "X albums you must hear yadda yadda yadda", listen, rate 'em and/or review 'em.

I never said it was an original idea. I wanted to just listen to and digest all these albums and discuss them with people I like talking about music with. ITT: AP.net

[FeynmanWannabe]

Originally Posted by NarcolepsySmile

I never said it was an original idea. I wanted to just listen to and digest all these albums and discuss them with people I like talking about music with. ITT: AP.net

I didn't complain that it wasn't. I was just pointing out an alternate list that many other people had used as a jumping off point for similar ventures, as well as a place where you might find the end outcome of some of these people's projects.

[J.C.]

Originally Posted by SlappedActor

That would take almost five years.

You got somewhere to be?

[irthesteve]

Originally Posted by FeynmanWannabe

I don't see how the idea is different: Take a publication's "X albums you must hear yadda yadda yadda", listen, rate 'em and/or review 'em.

This sounds like more of a discussion, like an album thread, than a review or a list, like an album review

[NarcolepsySmile]

Almost done with Sgt Peppers right now again. Listened to it last night but did again between my classes. Pet Sounds is awesome so can't wait to get to it again.

[Regards]

Wouldn't you want to start from 500 and work your way down to 1? I feel like you're going to loose a lot of people after 50 or so

[Regards]

Also were is my man J-Biebs? List is terrible.

[NarcolepsySmile]

Originally Posted by Regards

Wouldn't you want to start from 500 and work your way down to 1? I feel like you're going to loose a lot of people after 50 or so

Thought of that and figured if I were going to lose people I'd rather lose them in the 400's and have them miss the "best" ones.

[Lueda Alia]

I find these lists to favour old albums a lot more, which kind of makes sense, but it would be nice if newer albums could also break the Top 10 from time to time.

[bandnamexmyname]

Or Pitchfork's lists, which are chronologically organized.

[NarcolepsySmile]

Originally Posted by Lueda Alia

I find these lists to favour old albums a lot more, which kind of makes sense, but it would be nice if newer albums could also break the Top 10 from time to time.

[sjb2k1]

i'm down, so sgt peppers and pet sounds? sounds like fun homework to me!

please don't make it 10 a week. i have enough trouble listening to the stuff already on my plate, haha

[Mirrorsandfevers]

I'm down to talk about awesome albums throughout the week. Always. Set it up!

[Cody Nelson]

I'd be down to do this.