10:36 AM on 08/24/11
this record is that good, it'll probably be a top 5 record for me as well.
11:29 AM on 08/24/11
probably because it's a really good record.
11:29 AM on 08/24/11
I can't say until I hear it, but it's hard to imagine any album good enough to justify how overblown this review is. But hey, if you're excited about it, yell that shit from the rooftops.
maybe it's just hard for you to imagine. review isn't overblown at all.
11:36 AM on 08/24/11
Who are you to tell Thomas or anyone else how much they can love an album, especially when you haven't even heard it? this is such a shitty attitude to have. You come into this review thread and offer nothing constructive to it.
11:46 AM on 08/24/11
Never told Thomas how much he can love it. Where did I do that again? I'm glad he loves it. I specifically said he should "shout it from the rooftops." Direct quote.
Also, after the 4 seconds it took you to rush to his rescue, I put in an edit praising the quality of the writing, which is something I know he's worked really hard on. Constructive!
My contention is that it's silly to start throwing around hyperbole for an album that hasn't been out that long. Saying that he's "the future of rock and roll", saying that he's on a par with what Springsteen did in the 70's. Maybe when it shakes out, that'll be true. Who knows? But it's certainly way too early to say that about any album. We haven't even finished 2011 yet. Let alone had time to establish the kind of historical context Thomas is throwing around.
that's cool. You probably would have been that guy in the 70s too saying the same stuff about Springsteen haha
11:47 AM on 08/24/11
I can name like 20 albums from my lifetime I'd give 10s to. Some people have more lax scoring mechanisms in their heads than others.
I could probably name 10. maybe.
11:52 AM on 08/24/11
shaped everything I know and love about music.
11:54 AM on 08/24/11
Does that make Landau's claim less valid because he didn't wait 20 years to see how it all shook out? They're predictions, statements in the now -- not retrospective epitaphs. That's the point of saying them in the now. If you wait until after it happened, you're just summing up a career. I think it's important for music writers to take a stand, passionate ones, and go out on limbs like this. I encourage it. I was called out of my mind when I said Deja Entendu would change the music scene; it's one of the few predictions I've gotten right over the years. But I'm still glad I said it.
I remember the shit you got for your Say Anything Is A Real Boy review.
11:55 AM on 08/24/11
Yeah, I would have. If you're going to imply, directly or indirectly, that something is going to be joining the greatest of all time, it'd be useful to to see if it's still your favorite even a year from now. You can praise a record, even hyperbolically praise a record, without pulling out sweeping generalizations about it's place in history.
well considering that Thomas has been a fan of Brian Fallon for a while, I am sure he'll still be a favorite a year from now. We get it, you wouldn't take a risk with a prediction, it's okay.
11:56 AM on 08/24/11
it's really nothing like previous Gaslight stuff.
11:57 AM on 08/24/11
Hhaha, I could name 40.
Actually, I don't even care. I like an album, I like some albums more than others, I'm not in the "let's rank every single album I own" stage. That's sort of all that matters to me.
same, the only definite 10's in my lifetime are White Pony, Kid A, Full Collapse, Vheissu, and of course the new Bon Iver album.
11:59 AM on 08/24/11
So okay, send me a PM in 10 years and we'll discuss this record. If I'm right, that's pretty awesome. If I'm wrong, well I probably will be wrong about lots of things. Last year I never said anything in a review like I did in this one.
I appreciate Jason's post because I feel the same way. Rather than a cut and paste review of another record I loved, I wrote what I really thought about this one...and if I make one prediction like that every 150 reviews, I think I'll be okay with how they shake out.
Actually worth noting that this is the second record this year that I have said something bold about - but I have full faith in both Elsie and Suburbia. They will be 1-2 atop my list, and although it's only August, I've heard most of my anticipated releases up through early October.
that's another thing. when people say "how can you be so sure about where it'll be on your list?!?!", they don't realize how much we've already heard for the rest of the year haha
12:00 PM on 08/24/11
it'd be a 10 if we were using a /100 scale haha
12:10 PM on 08/24/11
I think I liked two songs? I give an extra 5 points for the cool music video. haha
More From This Author