As much as I love Brand New, I think this is kind of a shitty set. Too much YFW and Deja and not enough Devil & God and Daisy. I mean, not even one song from Daisy?
I agree about Devil & God but Daisy is easily their worst album (aside from YFW- which I don't even see as part of the bands discography since it's so radically different). You don't follow up a masterpiece that Devil was with an album like Daisy. Its a good record but the least ambitious/exciting IMO.