while I'll have to respectfully disagree...that record is one of the most underrated albums in the 2000-2005 screamo/hardcore/emo scene thing deal that happened.
i dunno man, to each his own i suppose, but that record is pretty much the perfect melodic hardcore record. the instruments just match each other so tightly, and the raw production just makes it feel that much realer. plus, to me at least, while still being a good band, they never were able to maintain the level of creative hook. that lineup showed a lot of pop writing restraint that really pushed them beyond, and they kinda lost that from ignite and rebuild onward, often going with clean vocal parts that went just a hair overboard, at least for my tastes.