Album Review
Alesana - A Place Where the Sun is Silent Album Cover

Alesana - A Place Where the Sun is Silent

Reviewed by
Alesana - A Place Where the Sun Is Silent
Record Label: Epitaph
Release Date: October 18, 2011
In a genre as crammed as post-hardcore, it’s easy to become bored with the mundane. As more and more teens flood Purevolume with their generic breakdowns and predictable band names, I find myself more and more apt to ignore the cookie cutter style that has been whittled down to nothing more than mere sound.

However, when I begin to consider the genre obsolete, I look to one band in particular to resuscitate my love for the clean/unclean vocal combos and epic lead-ups to the foreseen, yet endearing, breakdowns. North Carolina’s Alesana is the deliverer from the heinous monotony their genre is afflicted with. I’m not alone in thinking this. Alesana has always been one of those bands that have a deeply committed fan base that will fully support whatever it is that they create.

Alesana’s latest effort, A Place Where the Sun Is Silent is the anticipated follow up to the breakout hit The Emptiness, a concept album loosely based on an Edgar Allen Poe poem. The Emptiness was well received by many who took the time to dive into the story and denounced by countless critics. As The Emptiness was my 2010 album of the year, A Place Where the Sun Is Silent had a lot to live up to in my eyes.

Alesana’s Epitaph debut has sixteen tracks yielding over an hour of listening. This, in itself, gave me optimism before I even pressed play. As I see it, longevity is creativity, and as far as that goes, Alesana’s got it. The Emptiness gave fans a good first look at what the band’s idea of a modern day rock opera could be. A Place Where the Sun Is Silent showed that they could polish that idea both sonically and creatively.

The progress in sound between the band’s major releases is impresses to say the least. While The Emptiness was intended to be frantic and unkempt, it also showed a huge development from the immature sound Where Myth Fades to Legend brought about. In the case of the latest release, the amount of refinement is imposing.

While the trademark screams of Dennis Lee are still predominantly prevalent and unchanged, the clean vocals of Shawn Milke seem more subdued than usual. While still powerful and melodic, they lack the shrillness that has become customary. This is on the production end of things however; Shawn is by no means holding back.

Musically, Alesana has taken enormous strides. A Place Where the Sun Is Silent features shrieking guitars, classical piano, orchestral interludes, and pop-washed melodies. Moreover, the use of choir, brass, strings, and spoken word is a true testament to the talent this band holds. They have again created a true opera, changing moods with sound. There are countless elements to the album that put it far above similar releases.

Pop tracks such as “A Forbidden Dance”, “Lullaby of the Crucified”, and “A Guilded Masquerade” provide plenty of catchy hooks. If it’s heavy you want, “Circle VII: Sins of the Lion” or “The Fiend” will satisfy. Of course, in true Alesana Style, there are a few piano heavy tracks that provide a marvelous contrast periodically throughout, “Vestige” being the preeminent of those. The variation allows for the gratification of a vast array of listeners.

If Alesana is known for one thing, it’s their ability to tell a story. A Place Where the Sun Is Silent follows a story inspired by Dante’s Inferno. Shawn Milke, an English major, has always had a way with taking the story I hated in high school and adapting fragments of that story into melodic masterpieces that I just can’t get enough of.

While I enjoy their spin on the Divine Comedy, it just doesn’t compare to The Emptiness. The story that accompanied their last record had me enchanted. A Place Where the Sun Is Silent falls just short. Perhaps that will change when I get my hands on the booklet and the full narrative, but until then, it’s just below the bar they set in 2010.

The thing about Alesana that I enjoy so much is the depth that they bring to every aspect of their music and the constant improvement and commitment that can’t be paralleled by any other band that you would normally find them on tour with. A Place Where the Sun Is Silent is a solid release with major improvements in the music and composition. I favorably recommend A Place Where the Sun Is Silent and all of Alesana’s music. Look past their emo exteriors and dig into the mystery these boys create.

TracklistAct One: The Gate
1.The Dark Wood Of Error- 2:13
2.A Forbidden Dance- 3:53
3.Hand In Hand With The Damned- 4:36
4.Beyond The Sacred Glass- 6:03
5.The Temptress- 4:21
6.Circle VII: Sins Of The Lion- 4:09
7.Vestige- 2:58
8.Lullaby Of The Crucified- 4:48 Act Two: The Immortal Sill
1.Before Him All Shall Scatter- 0:54
2.Labyrinth- 4:04
3.The Fiend- 3:57
4.Welcome To The Vanity Faire- 4:37
5.The Wanderer- 1:37
6.A Gilded Masquerade- 4:35
7.The Best Laid Plans Of Mice And Marionettes- 5:35
8.And Now For The Final Illusion- 3:43

Recommended If You LikeA Skylit Drive; blessthefall; Rad stories

This review is a user submitted review from Jacob Tender. You can see all of Jacob Tender's submitted reviews here.
Displaying posts 1 - 10 of 10
07:47 AM on 10/29/11
down with the fad
User Info.
fobmcrafi6's Avatar
Stoked about this album; rad review; did nt know they did concept albums, i ll have to get The Emptiness too!
03:18 PM on 10/29/11
User Info.
Hiroblack's Avatar
Great album. The story itself blew me away. Especially the ending. I wont spoil anything, but it was really good in my opinion
03:48 AM on 10/30/11
User Info.
vivatoto56's Avatar
Exciting seeing some decent reviews for this band. Most people look at them as a joke and don't even give them much of a try.

Nicely written and I totally agree. I am loving this album.
01:31 PM on 10/30/11
When I get home I'll get high alone
User Info.
Psib's Avatar
Just realized i hadn't listened to anything new in this genre for a while. i guess ill check this out
10:54 AM on 10/31/11
Rob McWilliams
i'm just bad bad bad for you
User Info.
Rob McWilliams's Avatar
Listening through this was a chore.

I mean, the instrumentation was good, it was good not to have to hear Dennis yelping as much as I've come to expect, and sure, it's miles ahead of any other album they've ever done, but they could have released a two-part album series and made it a lot more interesting. I found myself daydreaming throughout almost the entire second act.
10:23 PM on 11/06/11
We found love in a hopeless place
User Info.
Dystroxia's Avatar
"The Fiend" = best Alesana song ever
09:39 PM on 11/07/11
Get fucked by a giant metal bird.
User Info.
White's Avatar
This band gets substantially more shit than they deserve.

That said, the score is substantially too high.
05:36 PM on 06/25/12
Registered User
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
A Gilded Masquerade's my favorite on this record
09:39 PM on 12/06/12
Registered User
User Info.
GCPeppe's Avatar
better than most of what people call post-hc, but their music is losing quality.

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate