Don't get the hate, this sounds like a perfectly natural progression from their last album, minus synth. If this turns out to be radio rock, it'll be radio rock in the same way that From Under The Cork Tree was.
I would rather see the Stuck in the Middle video, perhaps them playing on a circular stage to a crowd of their regular fans and their newfound radio fans, with both fans hating it and enjoying it at various parts.
(Get it? Because they're stuck in the middle)
That's at least as creative as this concept. Song is definitely growing on me though.
man joe is really growin his hair out haha. I feel like these songs will only be enjoyable in a live setting. right now i could hear this song on any modern rock radio station and if i didn't know of FYS i wouldn't bother to find out who it was playing on the radio