I liked there second record, but I've always felt that this band never recieved more attention because of how generic his voice is. To me there is just no distinctive qualities to it. Cover sounds amatuer-ish
People can be overly critical sometimes. I work in the gaming industry and I see the same thing every day, just enjoy what is put in front of you and, as you've astutely said, 'don't overthink' things'!