Wrong. Pinkerton is the sound of a band at their creative and musical peak. When I first heard both albums, I thought Blue was obviously the best. But once I gave it a chance to grow on me, Pinkerton revealed itself as the obvious winner.
I realize there's no 'right' or 'wrong' in this discussion.
Haha, I should've phrased it: Both albums are equally great, in my opinion, and important to who I am today and the music I've discovered, grown to listen to, liked and/or loved, over the years.