I despise Truth or Dare and the chorus to Stutter but other than those it's pretty great. Surprised that with all the Masterpiece Theater love no one talks about Fix Me though. It's still their best work IMO.
I like Fix Me. It has amazing songs but I think as a whole complete and cohesive album Masterpiece Theatre is their best. It is the perfect balance of pop and rock set to a larger than life feel and flows perfectly from start to finish. Fix me is great but does not contain something special that keeps the flow of the album. Ever After does keep a strong album flow and feels complete as well. I like Masterpiece Threatre more than Ever After though for being more balanced and less production. Ever After is still a great pop album though.