I have never given ANY album or band anywhere near a full score before. Albums can only get a full score with age in my opinion. This site gives far too many, so feel free to criticize me.

Originally Posted by OurLadyCoolbean

Pumpkins are my favorite band, but Gish has always been their album I've listened to the least, don't really have a reason for that though. I'd get this if I had the money to shell out :(

What order do you guys hold their albums in order of quality?

Mellon Collie>Gish>Siamese>Machina I>Zeitgeist>Adore>>>>>everything else.

I think Machina part 1 should really get a lot more love. Yeah, it was about 20 minutes too long but there are some really great tracks on there. I cannot wait to hear the Machina double album re-release. That is going to be the highlight of this whole release thing for a lot of people.

Also, did you follow SPRC?
http://www.absolutepunk.net/showthread.php?t=2564172