Originally Posted by sickydicky

i dont think anyone should be backing the matt geise thing. i was at the show and he was close to terrible, couldnt hack those vocals at all. the band was great but honestly despite how much everyone loves to hate jonny and and all his personal shit, the band is at its most solid when hes in it

I can't disagree more. Personally my favorite DGD era was early 2009 when they released Happiness. It featured their most consistent and harmonious lineup with just one vocalist and Will handling screams. That era was them when (I imagine) they were having the most fun, and their live shows were always diverse because you'd never know what DBM song they'd play in case they needed to please any Kurt-naysayers (and Kurt would always handle DBM songs greatly). After Mess rejoined in 2010 it rendered the band, well, a mess as far as their lineup is concerned.

Jonnys undeniably talented but his talents are best appreciated in the studio. His antics and his vulgarities on the road and on stage bring the band down a lot of notches in my book.

Originally Posted by bogusburrito

First things first, to prefer will over jon mess by any means discredits this whole paragraph of shit you vomited all of these boards. Will is the last person in the world that should touch a mic. I can't help but argue the fact you think happiness is the more consistent line up when there's dbm2. JC is the bread and butter of the band. kurt is better off in a lot like birds, and matt should honestly go back to ripping off daryl in his shitty band and stay away from dgd.

Hahahaha so many stupid points here.

I do prefer Will over Jon simply because Will can cover Jon's material live and therefore renders Jon's presence kind of pointless at live shows. Wills not the bests screamer but is it bad enough that they need to bring in another person onto the stage to clutter it even more? No. And Jonny is NOT the bread and butter of this band. They did remarkably well without him. But I guess that's just a matter of opinion, isn't it dickhead?