American Idol's Colton Dixonhas a lil' crush on Paramore's Hayley Williams. Pssst, Colton: Chad does that MMA stuff. Oh, and I apologize for that pun in the title - it's ridiculous and I know it.
His crush might have affected his song choice in his first live performance on the show seeing how he chose this one. I was guessing he was more focused trying to get her attention and trying to impress her by singing one of her songs on national tv and took a risk of getting eliminated from the show.