HLW is classic, Witness was a great follow up and surprisingly memorable. Awakening is...unmemorable. It's similar to Witness but it really lacks interesting guitar leads and clean vocal parts. Meet Me At the gates is good as are some others but overall it's pretty average :/
His Last Walk is still on rotation regularly for me. It is a great album. Witness has its moments for sure, I like the intro just because live It just brings a ton of energy. Their singles are DEFINITELY their better songs with Beau though, where as with Craig I like all the songs. I agree with Weltall, Meet me at the gates is one of my favorites from this one. Meet Me At the Gates, 40 days and Bottomfeeder are really the only ones i still play.