In the new issue of Entertainment Weekly (McDreamy from Grey's Anatomy on the cover), they have given Jimmy Eat World's Chase This Light an "A". Let's say, hypothetically, that you had heard the album already (which you couldn't because it is not in stores)--what would you rate it?
I like how Patrick Dempsey doesn't have a name and is now referred to as McDreamy :-D
I haven't heard the album or the demos (forreal. I refuse to spoil my most anticipated Tuesday this year) but I'm going to give them an A based on my knowledge of their past efforts. Sort of like how the Academy will give someone an Oscar even if their performance in that year's film wasn't that great because they deserved it from their past films.