A new singer can work out great but the fact that basically every member is new including the singer makes this ridiculous.
How could you possibly like the new singer of Saosin over Anthony Green??? or the 2 other singers of Further Seems Forever over Chris Carrabba?? Those are 2 blasphemous statements... not to take away from FSF, both their proceeding singers after Chris were amazing, but you still cannot beat The Moon Is Down!!