[RyanGarner]

Their first three are all just about tied for me. What's your favorite?

[tonyC4L]

I'm a huge Coheed fan so please don't take this as a typical "I only like their old stuff" sort of comment but it's close between the first two albums for me. Lately I've been feeling SSTB more though, so I'm going with that.

[speakhandsforme]

I believe that Good Apollo surpasses all their previous and later work by leaps and bounds. Such a masterpiece.

[Garcia1]

Great

[moreneon]

Originally Posted by speakhandsforme

I believe that Good Apollo surpasses all their previous and later work by leaps and bounds. Such a masterpiece.

I have to agree with this.

[Feenucks]

Originally Posted by RyanGarner

Their first three are all just about tied for me. What's your favorite?

The first three are pretty much tied for me as well. Went with Good Apollo. For the longest time that was the only album I would listen to.

Also, I'm not one of those "I like the old stuff" guys. I absolutely love ALL of their albums.

[speakhandsforme]

Oh, just to rank them:

1. Good Apollo
2. In Keeping Secrets
3. Second Stage Turbine Blade
4. Year of the Black Rainbow
5. No World for Tomorrow

[RyanGarner]

Originally Posted by speakhandsforme

Oh, just to rank them:

1. Good Apollo
2. In Keeping Secrets
3. Second Stage Turbine Blade
4. Year of the Black Rainbow
5. No World for Tomorrow

My rankings would look a little like this:

1. Second Stage
2. In Keeping Secrets
3. Good Apollo
4. No World for Tomorrow
5. Year of the Black Rainbow

but the top three and bottom two switch places a lot.

[tonyC4L]

Originally Posted by RyanGarner

My rankings would look a little like this:

1. Second Stage
2. In Keeping Secrets
3. Good Apollo
4. No World for Tomorrow
5. Year of the Black Rainbow

but the top three and bottom two switch places a lot.

Yeah this is basically me as well, and I still really like YOTBR.

[RyanGarner]

Originally Posted by tonyC4L

Yeah this is basically me as well, and I still really like YOTBR.

Same here, I think it's a great album but their first three are just so good that even an album like YOTBR seems a bit weaker than it really is.

[Protested Hero]

Iks
Sstb
Ga1
Ga2/yotbr

[SLoT]

No World is my favorite. I am the only one.

[phil19]

in keeping secrets will always be my favourite. i think its the strongest as an overall whole

[CoheedForever]

Have to go with Good Apollo but it switches from time to time. If my username didn't make it obvious enough, I love all their albums.

[suicidesaints]

In Keeping Secrets then 2nd stage