Really? Fair-weather fans? The logic I'm seeing here is that if someone dislikes anything in a band's discography, they're a fair weather-fan.
And for the record I liked Paint It Golden
I guess I'm just talking about the people who are like "oh my gosh I love Lydia so much, they're so incredible, blah blah blah" (or any band for that matter) when actually they only like one album.
Just in general, I think a lot of people on here like to criticize everything even though they don't play music or know much about it. That's like me scrutinizing everything about skateboarders and the X games or some crap when I don't know anything about it.