I expected to hate this but I didn't.

I like this way better than her recent single.

Not gonna lie, I cried at the end. She got me again!

If you listen to just the guitar it reminds me of third eye blind

Such a beautiful, heartfelt track. The story behind the song just makes it all the more devastating.

Such a sincere, beautiful track. Reminded me in some way to Yellowcard's Ten... I sincerely respect her work a lot more now, girl writes good songs and this is prove of it...

there are very few taylor swift songs i do not like. shes such a talented songwriter. and shes only what? 23?

Beautiful.

Heartbreaking song.

Sad stuff but the lyrics were still kinda meh. This will still tear up the charts though.

Between this and Kellie Pickler shaving her head in support of Cancer patients, wow.

Would like to see more of this from Taylor as oppose to something like "We are Never Ever Ever Getting Back Together".

She's fantastic when she decides to use her powers for good instead of spite.

Wow. This better be on Red. Beautiful emotional tune!

I'm not sure what's more heartbreaking: the lyrics or that she's capable of writing something as beautiful as this, yet makes another tactless breakup song her single. Both songs are clearly doing well and this kind of music is more becoming of her age versus "We Are Never Ever Ever Ever Ever Getting Back Together Ever".

Ugh I just went on a rant about her the other day about how much I dislike her songwriting and the image she portrays of young women in their 20s (I'm 22) and then she goes and does this. Also, the story of her and Kevin McGuire always made me tear up.

Fuck, I can't hate her.