I did a quick Google search and didn't come across a thread like this already.
The following is a list of records that I'm surprised haven't been pressed yet and that I'd pay good money to see on wax.
All Time Low - Put Up Or Shut Up
Allister - Last Stop Suburbia (they did test pressings but never put any more out)
Cartel - Chroma
Hawthorne Heights - If Only You Were Lonely
Hit the Lights - This is a Stickup, Don't Make it a Murder
Hit the Lights - Skip School, Start Fights
Just Surrender - If These Streets Could Talk
Lucky Boys Confusion - Throwing the Game
Lucky Boys Confusion - Commitment
Midtown - Living Well Is The Best Revenge
New Found Glory - Catalyst
New Found Glory - From The Screen to Your Stereo I & II
Rufio - MCMLXXXV
Saosin - Saosin (full length)
The Starting Line - Based on a True Story
Something Corporate - Leaving Through the Window
Story of the Year - Page Avenue
Sum 41 - Does This Look Infected?
The Years Gone By - Forever Came Too Soon
V/A - Punk Goes Acoustic
V/A - Atticus...Dragging the Lake.
What about you guys?