I don't know how old that would be but I would have been rather young. So I won't have any nostalgia influencing my feelings about them so I can see they're just pretty decent pop punk albums. s/t is better in pretty much every way I think.
I think that's what it is for me. I was in 5th, 7th, and 9th I believe for the previous three albums. Growing up skateboarding and playing music, those albums just did it for me way more than Neighborhoods does now. Self-titled is always going to be my favorite though.