Geddy's voice is great. It fits the music and it has character. PTH is just generic metalcore to begin with, topped with vocals that don't fit, it's a bad combo. There is nothing special about this band in the least.
Protest isn't a generic metalcore band. They're not generic and they're not metalcore. Show me another band that sounds just like PTH, and show me where there's any hardcore influence in their sound.
No? Yeah, like I said, fuckyouverymuch.