Don't enjoy their older albums as much despite how much I respect them. They pretty much created the metalcore genre, but it's been done to death now a thousand times better. Here's hoping they come off their hiatus soon.
1. You Come Before You
3. I/II/III EP's
4. Tropic Rot
5. Tear From The Red
6. The Opposite of December
I'd say I agree. I became a fan with the release of TFTR but I never could get really into TOOD. Well, moreso I stopped listening to it after the genre increased in popularity and more choices became available.
Here's my ranking (don't have I/II/III/IV)
1) You Come Before You
2) Tear From The Red
4) The Opposite Of December
5) Tropic Rot - only listened to this one maybe twice. I didn't give it enough time to appreciate it.
6) Distance Makes The Heart Grow Fonder