[seanzor]

Tropic Rot
Tear from the Red
I/II/III
Opposite of December
You Come Before You
Versions


I fell in love with Tropic Rot and don't understand why people never got into it. YCBY is that album I think people tend to love because it's how they found Poison the Well and it's how people rate everything they hear after, but maybe that's me being a dick. I was sad they went on hiatus after Tropic Rot because I felt they had just got back into what made me love them to begin with.

[kazuma_ootaro28]

You Come Before You
The Opposite of December
Distance Makes the Heart Grow Fonder - was also influential to me, but damn I haven't listened to this in so long.
The Tropic Rot
Versions
Tear From the Red

I haven't heard I/II/III yet, but I loved the demos before Versions (and I think some tracks made it on the EPs).

[Dre Okorley]

1. Opposite of Dec
Once the next album was released, I heard a few tracks and just didn't bother after that. I guess I had been expecting TOD pt II or huge influences from it, but that was it for me.

[Big_Guy]

Versions
YCBY
The Tropic Rot

the other ones suck so I will not include them

[signal to noise]

my ranking was already said, but

1) You Come Before You
2) Tear From the Red
3) Versions
4) Opposite of December
5) Tropic Rot

i like the I/III stuff but I dont know where i'd rank it

[JimGray]

Originally Posted by Alex DiVincenzo

The Opposite of December will always be my favorite. But You Come Before You is probably their best.

This

[floormaster925]

versions
you come before you
tear from the red
tropic rot
the opposite of december

[vegasbabyvegas]

Originally Posted by Every Time I Ty

Check out You Come Before You , to me it's just an all round improved version of Tear From The Red

This. I love YCBY.

[deanster321]

You Come Before You > The Tropic Rot > Tear from the Red > Versions > The Opposite of December

[cutebunniez182]

So sad to see The Opposite Of December so low on everyone's list... that was and still is my favorite.