The rarest record I own is the limited red press of Dig Up The Dead by Mansions.
Holy grails:
MMHMM - Relient K
The Vinyl Countdown - Relient K
The Alchemy Index boxset - Thrice

Originally Posted by Pappageo

Not sure there is any demand for it but any Days Away would be awesome.

Theres a lot of shit that there's not much demand for that gets pressed, but if you did a small run of like 500 I think it'd sell, personally. Plus you can always push it to Good Old War fans too.

Originally Posted by PerfectChaos337

I'd love to see AFI's Sing The Sorrow repressed for it's 10 year anniversary this year. It's my favorite piece of music ever, and it's a total pain to track down on vinyl these days.

Hoping to see Coheed's Good Apollo 1 pressed eventually. It's the most commendable of the band's catalog and their biggest commercially. Very surprised that it hasn't been pressed yet. i know there were plans not too long ago, but it seems like they fell through.

As far as stuff that will probably never happen - I would be so absolutely stoked if either of the 2 Emanuel records got pressed. FATA's stuff too, now that I think about it. Vagrant should make that happen.

I think it's strange to read because Sing the Sorrow sat in the Adeline record site for sale for the longest before the pressing sold out.

Originally Posted by Crimson_Curse

Would love to see/get:

The Academy Is... - Almost Here
Acceptance - Phantoms
Autopilot Off - Make A Sound
The Bled - Pass The Flask/Found In The Flood
Emanuel - Soundtrack To A Headrush
Envy On The Coast - Lowcountry
Fairweather - If They Move...Kill Them
From Autumn To Ashes - ANYTHING
Gatsby's American Dream - Volcano
He Is Legend - I Am Hollywood
Hidden In Plain View - Anything
The Kinison - What Are You Listening To?
Matchbook Romance - Anything
The Matches - Anything
Much The Same - Survive
Vendetta Red - Sisters Of The Red Death
Vaux - anything

Vendetta Red is like 18 bucks on Amazon.

Originally Posted by The Indiecast

Holy Grails:
Get Up Kids - Something to Write Home About error press on clear, only 5 copies made. Had a chance at one once, but couldn't pull the trigger at $400.

Most Prized in My Collection:
Brand New - Deja
Thrice - Vheissu (1st press)
JEW - Clarity (1st press on blue)
Mineral - Both LP's
As Tall As Lions - S/T (1st press autographed)
Get Up Kids/Coalesce split 7 test press 11/12

Need To Be Pressed:
Gatsbys - Volcano and S/T
Boys Night Out - S/T
As Cities Burn- Come Now Sleep and Hell or High Water
The Bled - PTF and FITF
Recover - Ceci n'est pas recover and Rodeo
Open Hand - The Dream
Ozma - Rock and Roll part 3
Pistolita - Oliver Under the Moon
Days Away - Entire Catalog

Entire Collection
http://deadformat.net/tradelist/struggle2recover

amazing collection

Holy eff I didn't know my Everything In Transit LP was that rare/ worth that much...

Originally Posted by brookssurrender

it will never happen, but:

This.

SoCo was always THE one album I wanted on vinyl.... probably my favourite album of all time. NOW, I'd say the following...

Limbeck - Hi, Everything's Great
New Found Glory - Catalyst / Coming Home (to complete my collection)
The Format - Interventions and Lullabies

A lot of those I have now WERE Holy Grails... The most obvious, that I have purchased fairly recently in the grand scheme of things were

Something Corporate - Leaving Through The Window
Refused - The Shape of Punk To Come
Incubus - Morning View
RX Bandits - Progress
Give Up The Ghost - We're Down Til We're Underground

My holy grails (fuck you, I have two) are probably The Fragile by Nine Inch Nails and The Devil and God on white. I'd kill for a re-pressing of The Room's Too Cold, and I will not be content with this world until The Mother, The Mechanic, and The Path is pressed.

Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge needs a repress. I've been dying to get my hands on that.

If I could have any vinyl record I wanted and money was no object, I'd want The Beatles - Yesterday & Today with the butcher-baby cover.

Slightly more realistic records I'd like:
Autopilot Off - Make a Sound
Over It - Silverstrand
The Monkees - Head (was repressed on colored vinyl earlier this year, but sold out before I could buy it)

And a ton of things people have already mentioned, like Acceptance and Jimmy Eat World.

Originally Posted by The Indiecast

Holy Grails:
Get Up Kids - Something to Write Home About error press on clear, only 5 copies made. Had a chance at one once, but couldn't pull the trigger at $400.

Most Prized in My Collection:
Brand New - Deja
Thrice - Vheissu (1st press)
JEW - Clarity (1st press on blue)
Mineral - Both LP's
As Tall As Lions - S/T (1st press autographed)
Get Up Kids/Coalesce split 7 test press 11/12

Need To Be Pressed:
Gatsbys - Volcano and S/T
Boys Night Out - S/T
As Cities Burn- Come Now Sleep and Hell or High Water
The Bled - PTF and FITF
Recover - Ceci n'est pas recover and Rodeo
Open Hand - The Dream
Ozma - Rock and Roll part 3
Pistolita - Oliver Under the Moon
Days Away - Entire Catalog

Entire Collection
http://deadformat.net/tradelist/struggle2recover

Would you consider trading your second press copy of Clarity?

Originally Posted by mka12992

My holy grails (fuck you, I have two) are probably The Fragile by Nine Inch Nails and The Devil and God on white. I'd kill for a re-pressing of The Room's Too Cold, and I will not be content with this world until The Mother, The Mechanic, and The Path is pressed.

seriously

Originally Posted by KenneyBN

Holy eff I didn't know my Everything In Transit LP was that rare/ worth that much...

it's not. sell it to me for 30

Originally Posted by jordalsh

seriously

I actually nerded out and drew up a few ideas for how I'd like it to be pressed. Haha. That's how much I want it. I really don't think it would have to be that expensive. Plenty of bands/artists make triple LPs, I don't see why that would be an issue. And considering how hardcore the TEN fanbase is, I could see it selling well enough.