Surprised "Sugar, we're goin' down" got beat out by a few of those...

EDIT: No starting line?

Originally Posted by zachff

This list is pointless because defining "emo" is like trying to grab the wind.

I agree. "Finch" doesn't fall into the same category as "Jack's Mannequin"

Originally Posted by loveisdead

Not sure how Best of Me by the Starting Line isn't on there. I don't get how Say Anything was completely omitted. And I sure as hell don't get how Helena ends up in the top spot. Or how Make Damn Sure is ahead of Cute Without the E. It's not the worst list ever, I just don't get some of the rankings and band omissions.

Yeah, i kept looking through the list for that one.

Originally Posted by GetUpAndrew

Personally, I would have added some Senses Fail, Hidden In Plain View, From First To Last, Silverstein, and '90s emo such as Braid or Mineral (both bands should have been on this list, along with the aforementioned acts)

Senses fail is on there unless you're just saying you wish they chose a different song or something...

Originally Posted by GetUpAndrew

Dude I just checked out twice the chart and didn't notice Senses Fail. Maybe you were referring to Sense Field, didn't you? Otherwise, I must be blind.

Oh shit, you're right haha. I posted "I can't believe The Starting Line and Senses Fail aren't on the list" earlier and deleted Senses Fail because Senses Field tricked my eyes.

Originally Posted by NomarZednem

Yeahhhh. The Juliana Theory!

"Duane Joseph" was one of the first songs on my mp3 player back in the day, haha.