Caleb still needs to improve. He came into this early, but only on synth, so no one really scrutinized him. Now that he's a frontman, he's got huge expectations, and I still think his vocals are a little weak all around (although they're waaay better). I prefer his AA! self-titled lows, but I think he can work on these to make them better over time. I'm impressed. Love that he's not playing with such a generic band anymore too.
Side note, really hurt to see that hate for Alesana. They were one of my favorite bands getting into this genre, and I still love that album haha. Oh well. To each his own I guess.