It's hard to place their new record in a top 5, since I've only listened to it like 7 times, so although I've been enjoying it a lot, I'll leave it out of my top. anyway, Discovering the Waterfront has been one of my favourite records ever for a few years, so it'll easily take the first place for me.
1 - Discovering the Waterfront
2 - A Shipwreck in the Sand
3 - Rescue
4 - Arrivals and Departures
5 - Short Songs
6 - When Broken is Easily Fixed
I can totally understand not ranking TIHTWS because it's so new. I felt comfortable doing so because I have had the album for about 2 and a half months now haha