It is just you. That album is easily one of the best heavy albums (all around albums for me) to come out in a long time. Every second of it oozes classic.
This whole concept is going to be very relative based on one's tastes obviously. I love maybe 1/2 of those entires but BMTH is the only classic for me. Such a shame with fun. though. Really sick of hearing them. I agree with the person who said Marianas Trench's Ever After would be a classic.