I love it, when a metal band goes soft, they get accused of selling out... but when adtr starts making heavier songs people complain. I personally love their heavier stuff. So does practically everyone at their concerts. Homesick was their weakest album.
You think Homesick was their weakest? I don't know man, I think it was the album that shot them into stardom. For me, FTWHH and Homesick are their strongest so far. WSMFY was decent, but not as good as the others.